Your Fonts Are Killing Me: The Top 3 Mistakes I See on Squarespace Sites
Spoiler alert: Just because it’s listed in Squarespace doesn’t mean you should use it.
Fonts are like outfits for your words. They can be chic, sharp, powerful, or completely wrong for the occasion. And just like crocs with a cocktail dress, I see some… questionable combos on Squarespace sites. Here are the top 3 font mistakes I see, and how to fix them.
Mistake #1: Using Too Many Fonts
One font for headers, one for body, one for buttons, one that just kinda showed up somewhere in a blog post… Sound familiar?
Why it’s a problem:
It feels chaotic, amateur, and totally unintentional. Plus, too many fonts slow down your site and confuse your reader.
Fix it:
Stick to two fonts: one for headings, one for body. That’s it. Okaaay, maybe one script font/
Pro tip: Choose contrasting styles (like a bold serif headline + a clean sans-serif body).
Mistake #2: Fancy Fonts That Kill Legibility
I get it—you wanted ✨personality✨. But if I have to squint or guess what your headline says? We’ve got a problem.
Why it’s a problem:
If it’s not readable, it’s not working. Script fonts, ultra-light weights, and anything that looks like it belongs on a wedding invite? Use very sparingly.
Fix it:
Use decorative fonts only for accents—like one line in your logo or a callout, not your entire hero banner.
Mistake #3: No Hierarchy—Everything Screams or Whispers
If every heading is H1-size bold caps, and your buttons blend into your body text… yikes.
Why it’s a problem:
People skim. You need a visual hierarchy to guide their eyes and make content scannable.
Fix it:
Create a style guide:
H1: Bold and big (but use just once per page!)
H2: Smaller, still eye-catching
Body: Clear and comfy to read
Buttons: Contrast color + legible size
Final Word
If your site feels “off” but you can’t figure out why—it might be your fonts whispering chaos into your layout. Cleaning up your typography can make your whole site look custom (even if it’s still DIY).
👀 Want me to take a peek? Book a quick audit or 1:1 session and I’ll help you untangle the font mess—no judgment. You can email me here - just put HELP! in the subject line and I’ll swoop in with solutions.
